“[A] wide door for effective work has opened to me, and there are many adversaries” (1 Cor. 16:9).
In the Lord’s timing, the morning of September 11th, 2025, was the day I taught my first lesson to a class of Grade 11 Law students—Charlie Kirk had been murdered the day before. As you can imagine, Charlie’s death overshadowed any plans I’d previously made to open my lecture with a discussion of 9/11 and its lasting implications, or the then-recent murder of Iryna Zarutska on a North Carolina light-rail train just a few weeks prior.
It was only the second week of the new school year, and already the darkness was beginning to gather.
An Open Door
Becoming a teacher in Canada requires that you first earn an undergraduate degree, which is then followed by a blend of pedagogical lectures and in-school placements at an accredited teacher’s college. Last fall, I was in my third and final placement at a public high school, teaching a full course load of Law, Civics, and some amalgamation of Psychology/Sociology/Anthropology titled “Social Sciences and Humanities”.
I had met my Associate Teacher, who insisted I call him Finch, only the week before. As a seasoned teacher, it was still his classroom; but for the purposes of my final placement, it was more or less my classroom. For the next six weeks, my job was to teach, and his job was to supervise my teaching, with the hope that, in just over a month’s time, his students and classroom would be returned to him in at least the same condition they were given and ideally no worse.
Finch had a firm handshake, a sharp wit, and a style that was sharper still—both of dress and teaching—which set him oceans apart for the better from any other teacher I had ever met. “I read in the little bio you submitted for your placement that you’re a Christian,” he said to me near the end of our first day together, swirling around nonchalantly in his desk chair. Classes were due to begin the next day.
Here it comes, I thought.
Finch continued. “You’ll come to see that I run my classrooms a little differently than you might be used to—lots of discussions and debates on controversial topics, even if it means ‘less’ work is done. In my experience, that’s where the real learning has always happened. When you take over for me next week, and if you’re comfortable, I’d love for you to lean into that with a Christian perspective.”
Oh—well, that’s not what I expected.
“I would love to,” I replied, somewhat taken aback. One can never be too sure what kind of Associate Teacher they’ll be saddled with for the duration of their placement—or, for that matter, what kind of teacher you’ll have in general. Will they be for Christ or against him? By his own admission, Finch was no Christian. He was, however, raised in the church and supremely interested in open, honest discussions. That was a great start.
“Wonderful,” Finch replied as he rose from his seat with car keys in hand, sending his chair spinning once again as we made our way towards the parking lot. “And I will see you, sir, tomorrow!” And with that, he was off.
“Thank you, Lord,” I whispered as Finch drove away. For much of my own drive home, John 3:30 kept turning over in my mind: “[Christ] must increase; I must decrease.”
A teacher like Finch was perhaps the last person I expected to be teaching under, and for that I was immeasurably thankful. To be a light for Christ in the classroom was precisely the reason why so many believers became teachers to begin with—and, it would seem, precisely where the Lord would have me “for such a time as this” (Esth. 4:14).
Indeed, a great door had been opened.
The Doorway Widens
Portable Six, Finch’s classroom, stood a little ways off from the main school building. It was a standalone structure originally intended for student overflow which Finch had turned into his own private oasis, replete with dozens of political yard signs mounted over all the walls and desks, a large collection of memorabilia and student gifts from throughout the years, and even an Xbox for what he called “Free Fridays”. Like Finch , the classroom at Portable Six was something of a world unto itself—indeed, the two were meant for each other.
Driving to school the morning after Charlie Kirk was murdered is an experience I will never forget. By the time I pulled up to Portable Six, my lesson plans from the night before were already thrown out the proverbial window: I had prayed for an open door for the gospel; with Charlie’s death, God had not only widened the door, but blown it off its hinges entirely.
The fact remains that Charlie Kirk was murdered for boldly proclaiming many of the very same things that we as believers hold sacred and true. This doesn’t mean you must agree with everything he ever said. Kirk represented a powerful political operation, but he was also a bold witness for Christ and the truths of the Scriptures.
The previous evening, I had seen the venom and vitriol hissing from the lips of Charlie’s enemies over social media in the hours immediately following his death. What would my students have to say? Where did Finch stand in the midst of all this?
Even at the time, I felt there was something different about Charlie’s death; he was so bold in his public witness for Christ that there was no possibility the public discussion about his death could avoid the topic of the gospel.
As followers of Christ, it’s our joyful duty to be a light for him, no matter how closely the darkness encroaches, no matter the cost—and no matter the place. Having rubbed shoulders with the Canadian public school system for some time by this point, I more or less had an idea of what I was stepping into.
And so, on the morning of that September 11th, with as much humility and boldness as I could muster, and no small amount of prayer, I began that morning’s discussion with my students—not with 9/11, or Iryna Zarutska, or even Charlie Kirk, really, but rather with Christ and his Word.
But then something happened that I did not expect. To my everlasting surprise, I was met with respect, thoughtfulness, and a listening ear by many—if not most—of my students. And Finch, perhaps more than anyone else, came to my defence.
And so, all that morning, we talked about the things of eternity.
Were there some disagreements among us? Of course. Even severe dissension? Here and there. But was there venom or vitriol? Not a hint.
Indeed, I was wrong about my students. In preparing for the worst, I had also assumed the worst about them. Charlie’s murder shook my students too. Though many of them had criticized Charlie when he was alive, even they recognized that a line had been seriously crossed—not only by Charlie’s murderer, but by those who celebrated his death as well. They were hungry for a real explanation, for actual answers, or else an honest discussion that wasn’t weighed down with woke nonsense or political talking points. They yearned for the Truth; for the ultimate answers only God in Christ could provide.
That morning, in the wake of the most devastating of tragedies, the door had been widened for Christ and his gospel to such a degree that nothing and no one could now shut it.
And now that my students knew where I stood with respect to Christ, his Word, and his world, there was free passageway between us through this open door in the days and weeks which followed. All thanks to God, “[A] wide door for effective work has opened to me” (1 Cor. 16:9).
No topic, question, or controversy was off the table—as per Finch’s orders. Indeed, it was Finch who instigated, or else threw gasoline on, the most controversial of our class discussions, poking the beast as he sat perched in the corner behind his desk.
Given Finch’s course load that fall was Law, Civics, and Social Science, there arose no shortage of opportunities to meaningfully engage with what God’s Word said on a host of topics. As a class, we talked about it all: sin, capital punishment, abortion, homosexuality, homeschooling, free speech, slavery, evolution, creation, the need for salvation, always in some way circling back to Christ (whether or not my students realized it at the time). Indeed, an invisible hand was leading us toward some predetermined end.
All of it culminated in a single day, my last day; a day which will long echo in my memory, and no doubt into eternity itself.
One afternoon in class, a few minutes before the bell, we stumbled into a particularly interesting discussion about human rights—what makes a human a human? And where in the world do rights come from, anyway? Without God, isn’t it all just relative?
Our conversation had reached a fever pitch by the time the bell went off, marking the end of class—and our discussion. A collective moan rippled across the room as my students gathered their things. As they were filing out of the portable, catching Finch’s eye as though the idea were shared between us, I made a suggestion: “Hold up, folks. My last day here is coming up. What if, instead of having a normal class, we have a big, dirty, gloves-off debate on some really interesting and important topic?”
A collective cheer rippled across the room.
And with that, the big, dirty debate at Portable Six was decided.
The Big, Dirty Debate
At the time, and certainly thereafter, it seemed as though everything God had been up to in Portable Six led to the class debate on my final day. I say “debate”, but in reality it was The Class v. Mr. B. The idea was that I’d select a topic, and the students would argue for or against it, either together or individually; in support of my position or in direct opposition to it.
A few days before the big, dirty debate, I sent out an anonymous Google Form for my students to fill out with possible topics. Their suggestions began to flood in, ranging from “Religion is stupid and does more harm than good” to “Transgenderism is a mental illness”. Upon reading the latter suggestion, Finch remarked, “I know I get away with a lot around here, but even I might not be able to get away with that one. Best you pick something else.”
And I did choose another topic—one that was far more offensive and, in my opinion, far more loving.
Above all, I wanted my last day with these kids—and with Finch—to be a meaningful culmination of our time together. Since before I had met any of them, they were already in my prayers. I prayed that they would come to know Christ as Lord and Saviour, that they would repent of their sin, and that they’d come to know the One whom all their deepest longings and burning questions chased after.
My chief aim with the big, dirty debate wasn’t to offend for the mere sake of it, but to simply put Christ on display to the best of my ability, trusting that his Spirit would do the rest. I hoped to select a debate topic that not only piqued my students’ curiosity but also pricked their hearts.
And the Lord was certainly at work. Because of a Thanksgiving-themed fall event being held on the football field later that afternoon, my last day with the students had an alternate schedule. This meant that our class was twice as long as usual and bled directly into lunch, giving us all the time we needed to “duke it out”.
Word about the debate must have got around, because by the time I assumed my place at the front of the class, Portable Six was positively bursting. In addition to most of my students, a handful of others were in attendance whom I did not recognize. I suppose truancy among senior students isn’t so much of an issue provided you give them the chance to spar with their teacher.
With a deep breath and a prayer—“[Christ] must increase; I must decrease”—I began.
“First of all, I wanted to thank those of you who submitted suggestions for today’s debate. There were too many interesting ideas to choose from. So, rather than selecting one single issue, I decided on a topic that would hopefully provide ample ground for discussion on many of the things we’ve discussed during our time together. So, here it is—”
“Life without the Christian God is unintelligible and meaningless.”
I paused, allowing the words—and students—to settle for a moment.
“Now, allow me to clarify a few things before we get started. What I do not mean by this statement is that your life specifically is unintelligible or meaningless if you do not believe in the God of the Bible. Because God exists, you have value and purpose—full stop. Whether you believe it to be true or not, all of you are made in the image of God and are of immeasurable value. My utmost conviction is that the God of the Bible is the one true God, and because of this reality, life both makes sense and is filled with purpose.” Another pause. “So, what do you think?”
Immediately, a dozen or more hands rose in rapid response, their arms shooting high and straight like blades of wheat, white and ready for harvest.
Starting with the girl closest to me, I took their questions and objections one at a time.
Over the next hour and a half, Portable Six was awash with the richest conversation we had yet shared in as a class. Students who, up until that point, had not professed Christ both proclaimed him and took my side throughout the discussion, at times even engaging with their fellow students. Some who had scarcely said a word all semester began asking the most thoughtful questions; and others from whom I expected more remained silent, yet still with their eyes and ears ever tuned in to the conversation.
Even Finch himself was uncharacteristically quiet, listening from his swivel chair in the corner.
Among the more contentious, the usual suspects and criticisms were not far behind—“I’ve known plenty of Christians in my life, and almost none of them actually practise what they preach.” Or, “Haven’t you heard? The Bible is full of contradictions and mistakes. Believe me, I’ve read it.” One student was particularly hung up on why God didn’t allow the Israelites to eat shellfish. But above all, the conversation kept returning to one well-worn issue: “Why would a good God allow so much evil and suffering in the world?”
Some of my students kept pushing this question as a sort of “Gotcha”, as though their naturalistic worldview could explain why evil occurs, much less why such a thing even exists. Other students asked the question with a sincere heart—evil and suffering weren’t abstract concepts to them, but terrible realities they had themselves experienced.
And with their many questions, God opened the door further still.
I ended our time together by telling them how I came to Christ; how the Bible explained that he loved me; how he saved me from my sin; and how he was, in that very moment, calling each of them to faith and repentance as well. I told my students that I loved them; and above all, that Christ loved them. And because God had opened a door between us all those weeks ago—one which we as a class had since walked through many times with kindness and respect—I think they actually believed me.
“Over the past six weeks,” I began in conclusion, “we’ve talked a lot about meaning and purpose—and truth. What is truth? What does it matter that we have laws and moral standards if there is no such thing as truth and no God who judges truth from lies and good from evil?”
“In a purely naturalistic worldview,” I went on, “there is no God, no truth, no good, no evil, and certainly no justice for all the evil and suffering you have rightly recognized as a problem in our short time together. The theory of evolution cannot account for what you know to be true in your hearts. Evolution doesn’t have the language to speak about the good, the true, the beautiful—and the ugly. No: evolution says that, to survive, the strong must prey on the weak. In Christ, we see him who is strongest giving his life for those who are weakest—that’s what the gospel is all about.”
What Have You in Your Hand?
A few weeks before the big, dirty debate, an older brother in Christ nearing the end of his own teaching career encouraged me with the story of Moses and the burning bush from Exodus 4. Standing before the glory of the Lord, Moses persisted in half-hearted excuses for why he could not do what God was calling him to. Finally, out from the all-consuming inferno, the Lord asked Moses, “What is that in your hand?” (Exod. 4:2). Moses looked down and responded, “A staff.” Nothing was special about the staff. Like Moses, it was an instrument of salvation in the hands of a merciful Lord.
Dear brother and sister, wherever you may find yourself, do not run from that which God has placed in your hand. He intends to use you precisely where you are for his glory and the good of others.
With each new school year, I wrestle with both excitement and trepidation. There is so much work to be done for Christ in the classroom, but the work is hard, weighty, and can seem awfully lonely. However, when I reflect on those six weeks I spent with Finch, my heart draws courage from how the Lord worked—and is working.
Closing the classroom door of Portable Six for the final time was bittersweet. I was going to miss my students, but I knew they were in better hands than mine. Driving away on my last day, with the classroom door growing small in the distance, now closed for Thanksgiving weekend, I drew comfort from the fact that the real door remained wide open.
Indeed, God had so opened the door for Christ and his gospel that nothing and no one could now shut it: